Covers all matches played since the beginning of season 1938/39.
| Grade | Opponent | Season | Venue | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 95* | BARTLETT, Oliver (53*) | MAGAREY, Alec (62*) | B | Wiles | 1947/48 | South P'lands, Sth Tce |
| 93 | HOPKINS, Bob (53) | ANDERSON, John (40*) | A | National Australia Bank | 1980/81 | Henley Memorial Oval |
| 90 | NEWSON, Richard (63) | MARSHALL, Ken (30*) | D | Plympton Footballers V | 1995/96 | Hewett Oval |
| 90 | ROSE, Scott (49*) | KOIRALA, Jai (39) | A | Plympton Footballers | 2005/06 | Hewett Oval |
| 88 | PHILLIPS, John (41*) | MAGAREY, David (Snr) (50) | C | Fulham III | 1968/69 | Fulham P.S. |
| 85* | MCCAULEY, Jarrod (56*) | CATFORD, Adam (24*) | B | Warradale II | 2011/12 | Brighton H.S |
| 82* | POWELL, Dave (147*) | BAILLIE, Ivan (37*) | B | Shell | 1949/50 | South P'lands, Park Tce |
| 78 | MOORE, Ben (67) | NEGERMAN, Rob (18*) | A | Morphettville Park | 2007/08 | Hewett Oval |
| 77* | CARPENTER, Bruce (50*) | WORTHINGTON, Bruce (27*) | C | Plympton Footballers III | 1973/74 | Blackwood H.S. |
| 76 | HUNTER, Richard (26*) | CRAIG, Peter (50) | A | Westminster OS | 1991/92 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 75 | HAYDEN, Tim (51*) | BUSHAWAY, Roy (19) | D | Norwood Union II | 1985/86 | Brookway Park Oval |
| 73 | HEWETT, Bob (47) | SAUNDERS, Jack (21*) | A | Grange | 1945/46 | Hewett Oval |
| 70 | PARKER, Jeff (16*) | LITTLEFIELD, Jason (48) | C | North Haven II | 1986/87 | Hewett Oval |
| 66 | PENNO, Ray (18) | DODD, Steve (52*) | C | St Marks II | 1948/49 | East P'lands, D'ville Tce |
| 66 | MATTHEWS, Darrell (46*) | SQUIRE, Chris (25) | C | Sheidow Park | 1992/93 | Sheidow Park P.S. |
| 63 | ?, ? (46*) | ZACPAL, Peter (31) | B | Modbury Heights | 1989/90 | Heights School Middle Oval |
| 61 | ANDERSON, John (21*) | WAUCHOPE, Antony (31) | A | ANZ | 1981/82 | South Parklands |
| 61 | KNUCKEY, Kym (94*) | MABLESON, Roger (6) | A | Plympton Footballers | 1989/90 | Mitchell Park |
| 61* | HUNTER, Gus (26*) | WATCHMAN, Harold (41*) | A | Southwark | 1949/50 | Hewett Oval |
| 61* | GALLASCH, Paul (24*) | RAYMOND, Nick (33*) | B | Kenilworth | 2006/07 | Kenilworth Oval |
| 59 | HUNTER, Gus (81*) | HAMS, Gary (8) | C | Civil Aviation II | 1982/83 | Adelaide Airport |
| 59 | HUNTER, Richard (41*) | MAURICI, Lou (26) | A | ANZ | 1993/94 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 57 | JOHNSON, Ted (46*) | BUSHAWAY, Roy (13) | B | Keswick | 1980/81 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 56 | LLOYD, Rowan (72*) | RATHJEN, John (8) | D | Plympton Footballers VI | 1994/95 | Paringa Park P.S. |
| 55 | WEBBER, George (21) | MAGAREY, Roger (Snr) (27*) | B | Air Force | 1945/46 | Daws Rd, Colonel Light Gdns |
| 55 | MAGAREY, Roger (Snr) (27) | HUNTER, Gus (22*) | B | Wallaby | 1949/50 | Hewett Oval |
| 54 | REID, Bob (94) | HAYDEN, Phil (12*) | B | Blackwood R.S.L | 1965/66 | Hawthorndene Oval |
| 53 | MAGAREY, Rob (34*) | MAGAREY, David (Snr) (24) | C | Fulham III | 1969/70 | Blackwood H.S. |
| 51 | POWELL, Vere (35*) | SOUTHBY, George (21) | A | Southwark | 1945/46 | West parklands |
| 51 | GAMBLE, Graham (21*) | HAYDEN, Phil (21) | B | Civil Aviation | 1963/64 | Hewett Oval |
| 51 | CHEEK, Darren (62*) | BIRD, Thomas (10) | B | Plympton Footballers II | 2018/19 | Women's Memorial #1 |
| 51* | KEARSLEY, Greg (34*) | CARPENTER, Graham (13*) | D | North Haven IV | 2010/11 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 49 | HEWETT, Jack (45*) | STUART, Dick (20) | A | Sturt | 1953/54 | Hewett Oval |
| 49 | HUNTER, Gus (85*) | BROWN, L (15) | A | St Marks | 1965/66 | Hewett Oval |
| 49 | MAGAREY, David (73*) | WANNAN, Grant (14) | A | Glenelg ANA | 2003/04 | Hewett Oval |
| 49* | RATHJEN, Peter (49*) | ZACPAL, Peter (21*) | B | Sheidow Park | 1991/92 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 49* | ZACPAL, Peter (23*) | BIRD, Thomas (24*) | D | Woodcroft II | 2013/14 | Reynella East H.S. |
| 48 | WATCHMAN, Harold (53*) | BAILLIE, Ivan (15) | A | Ascot Park | 1947/48 | Hewett Oval |
| 48 | HUNTER, Gus (22*) | MABLESON, Roger (27) | A | Mitchell Park | 1973/74 | Mitchell Park Rec. Res. |
| 48 | WOOD, Leith (59*) | HARVEY, Andrew (13) | C | Mitchell Park III | 1993/94 | Darlington P.S |
| 48 | HIGGINS, Grant (27) | MUGGRIDGE, Anthony (25*) | B | Cove II | 2010/11 | Cove F.C. |
| 47 | PARKIN, Barry (47) | TANNEBRING, Reg (11*) | A | South Road | 1967/68 | Edwardstown Oval |
| 47 | MEEK, Nick (36*) | ZACPAL, Peter (12) | B | Kenilworth II | 1989/90 | Kenilworth Oval |
| 47 | ZACPAL, Peter (33) | SELLICK, Ben (14*) | C | Plympton Footballers III | 1999/00 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 46 | HAYDEN, Phil (20*) | WAUCHOPE, Steve (22) | B | Newton McLaren | 1969/70 | Hewett Oval |
| 45 | MAGAREY, Alec (74) | SEALY, F (20*) | D | Shell II | 1948/49 | South P'lands, Sth Tce |
| 45 | COOMBS, Ian (30) | HILLIER, Mark (14*) | B | South Road II | 1971/72 | Edwardstown Oval |
| 45 | RATHJEN, Peter (33*) | GRIFFIN, Peter (13) | B | South Road II | 1994/95 | Edwardstown Oval |
| 44 | STUTCHBURY, Mike (40*) | PRIESTLY, Brian (21) | B | South Road II | 1972/73 | Hewett Oval |
| 44 | GIGNEY, Stuart (31*) | MCMANUS, Josh (15) | C | Morphett Vale II | 2014/15 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 44* | MABLESON, Roger (43*) | ANDERSON, John (13*) | A | Warradale | 1986/87 | Camden P.S. |
| 44* | CAMPBELL, Stuart (84*) | RATHJEN, Peter (9*) | A | Morphettville Park | 1998/99 | Hewett Oval |
| 43 | NEEDHAM, Patrick (29*) | MAGAREY, David (17) | A | Mitchell Park | 2006/07 | Mitchell Park Rec. Res. |
| 43 | VAN SCHAIK, Tom (31*) | SCOTT, Ben (15) | B | Coromandel Ramblers II | 2015/16 | Hawthorndene Oval |
| 43* | HOPKINS, Bob (19*) | TANNEBRING, Reg (22*) | A | Kenilworth | 1978/79 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 42 | MULLINS, Tod (51*) | BUSHAWAY, Roy (1) | D | St George | 1985/86 | Hawthorndene Oval |
| 41 | HAYDEN, Phil (24*) | CRAIG, Peter (15) | B | Western Districts II | 1971/72 | Henley Beach H.S |
| 41* | RAJAN, Tarun (25*) | MCDONALD, Josh (22*) | C | Western Youth Centre III | 2007/08 | Cowandilla P.S |
| 40 | STUART, Dick (11) | ALLEY, Alf (31*) | A | St Marks | 1954/55 | Hewett Oval |
| 40 | PHILLIPS, John (18*) | HUNTER, Gus (28) | A | Western Districts | 1972/73 | Henley Beach H.S |
| 40 | JONES, Lauclan (26) | CARPENTER, Graham (11*) | B | Hectorville II | 1997/98 | Daly Oval |
| 40* | CRAIG, Peter (24*) | SULLIVAN, Sean (13*) | A | State Bank | 1987/88 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 40* | GRIFFITHS, Luke (11*) | WARD, Chris (27*) | D | Westminster OS II | 1996/97 | Hewett Oval |
| 39 | WATCHMAN, Alf (41*) | POWELL, Vere (6) | A | Y.M.C.A. | 1945/46 | Hewett Oval |
| 39 | LINCOLN, Malcolm (58*) | HAYDEN, Phil (7) | B | Happy Valley | 1967/68 | Happy Valley |
| 39 | WAUCHOPE, Antony (37*) | HUNTER, Richard (7) | B | Plympton Footballers II | 1983/84 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 39 | HAMS, Gary (9*) | WALSH, Mike (30) | E | Campbelltown II | 1983/84 | Newton Sports Gr. |
| 39 | MAGAREY, Andrew (26*) | KOIRALA, Jai (24) | A | Warradale | 2005/06 | Hewett Oval |
| 39 | KERNICH, Ben (17*) | MURPHY, Peter (21) | D | Kenilworth II | 2010/11 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 39 | MUGGRIDGE, Anthony (27) | DRAPER, Daniel (18*) | A | ICC Sharks | 2013/14 | Hewett Oval |
| 39 | BEENHAM, Henry (46*) | WALTON, Jack (14) | A | Plympton Footballers | 2022/23 | Plympton Oval |
| 39* | HOPKINS, Bob (19*) | HOUSTON, David (24*) | A | Kenilworth | 1973/74 | Hewett Oval |
| 38 | WATCHMAN, Alf (113*) | SCOTT, Bill (4) | A | Glenelg Stragglers | 1951/52 | Hewett Oval |
| 38 | JOHNSON, Ted (22) | MARSH, Keith (9*) | C | Sportsmen | 1981/82 | Hewett Oval |
| 38 | WALSH, Mike (32) | WANNAN, Grant (1*) | C | ANZ III | 1985/86 | Hewett Oval |
| 38 | ALDERSON, Andrew (62*) | ZACPAL, Peter (6) | C | Campbelltown/ANZ III | 1995/96 | Hewett Oval |
| 38 | MANGIN, Brodie (15) | ROXBY, Nathan (20*) | A | South Road | 2002/03 | Hewett Oval |
| 38 | SCOTT, Ben (38*) | NORMAN, Chris (15) | A | Morphettville Park | 2014/15 | Denham Reserve |
| 37 | SLEE, Arthur (28) | HALSTEAD, Bill (9*) | B | Brighton | 1956/57 | Hewett Oval |
| 37 | HUNTER, Gus (9*) | COGDELL, Ian (28) | A | Plympton Footballers | 1968/69 | Hewett Oval |
| 37 | YARDLEY, Ian (29*) | ZACPAL, Peter (23) | C | M.P.S.M. III | 1976/77 | Blackwood H.S. |
| 37 | PURSER, Chris (67*) | HALSTEAD, John (3) | B | Kenilworth | 1976/77 | Kenilworth Oval |
| 37 | CARPENTER, Ray (45) | MCFARLANE, David (7*) | B | National Australia Bank | 1979/80 | Henley Memorial Oval |
| 37* | MATTHEWS, Darrell (38*) | SQUIRE, Chris (13*) | D | Norwood Union III | 1991/92 | Paradise P.S |
| 37* | CAMPBELL, Stuart (36*) | WANNAN, Grant (7*) | A | Morphettville Park | 2001/02 | Hewett Oval |
| 36 | HALSTEAD, Allen (38*) | LESTER, Brian (12) | D | Clarence Park | 1949/50 | Blackwood |
| 36 | HAYDEN, Phil (19) | ALLEY, Alf (11*) | B | Healing Ltd. | 1953/54 | South P'lands, Sth Tce |
| 36 | MAGAREY, Roger (Snr) (37*) | SCHMIDT, Ron (16) | B | Belair | 1967/68 | Hewett Oval |
| 36 | WORTHINGTON, Bruce (29) | BARRINGTON, Mark (8*) | C | Adult Deaf | 1973/74 | Blackwood H.S. |
| 36 | SAKTHIVEL, Sundernathan (17) | BIRD, Thomas (19*) | C | Plympton Footballers III | 2009/10 | Marion P.S. |
| 36 | KEARSLEY, Greg (28*) | CARPENTER, Graham (15) | D | Adelaide Cavaliers | 2011/12 | Kenilworth No.2 Oval |
| 36* | CRAWFORD, Jim (53*) | HARMER, Glen (9*) | B | Seaview Downs | 1978/79 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 36* | HUNTER, Richard (34*) | BRIMBLE, Lee (11*) | B | Rosewater II | 1985/86 | Almond Tree Flat Reserve |
| 35 | HADDRICK, Eric (40*) | DODD, Steve (10) | C | Sturt II | 1947/48 | Blackwood |
| 35 | HEWETT, Bob (27*) | NOSWORTHY, Ted (8) | A | St Marks | 1955/56 | Hewett Oval |
| 35 | SLEE, Arthur (15*) | BROWN, L (32) | A | Coromandel Ramblers | 1965/66 | Hawthorndene Oval |
| 35 | PIVETTA, Lou (32*) | HAMS, Gary (18) | E | Mitchell Park V | 1984/85 | Hawthorndene P.S. |
| 35 | HUNTER, Richard (39) | MCDONOUGH, Andrew (14*) | B | Warradale II | 1985/86 | Warradale P.S. |
| 35 | HAGLEY, Tom (23*) | MAURICI, Lou (15) | A | Mitchell Park | 1993/94 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 35 | COULTER, Darren (28*) | GARARD, Aaron (9) | A | ICC Sharks | 2009/10 | Hackham Sports Club |
| 34 | HAYDEN, Phil (3*) | HERBERT, Herb (22) | B | St Marks | 1966/67 | South P'lands, Sth Tce |
| 34 | BEVERLEY, John (38*) | WANNAN, Grant (16) | A | Coromandel Ramblers | 2003/04 | Hawthorndene Oval |
| 34 | LAMING, Matt (24) | COCHRANE, Simon (12*) | A | Morphettville Park | 2006/07 | Hewett Oval |
| 34 | CARPENTER, Graham (26*) | ZACPAL, Peter (5) | D | Coromandel Ramblers IV | 2012/13 | Weymouth Oval |
| 34 | ZACPAL, Simon (24*) | ZSCHORN, Phil (10) | B | Belair | 2014/15 | Hewett Oval |
| 33 | WATCHMAN, Harold (34) | BAILLIE, Ivan (10*) | A | Y.M.C.A. | 1949/50 | South P'lands, Park Tce |
| 33 | HUNTER, Gus (104) | NOSWORTHY, Ted (1*) | A | Brompton | 1964/65 | St. John st. Brompton |
| 33 | WILSON, Graham (20) | PURSER, Chris (15*) | A | Coromandel Ramblers | 1975/76 | Hewett Oval |
| 33 | MORELLI, Nathan (21) | MCCAULEY, Jarrod (9*) | C | Plympton Footballers IV | 2003/04 | Paringa Park P.S. |
| 33 | MURPHY, Benjamin (35*) | BIRD, Thomas (2) | C | Morphettville Park III | 2013/14 | Seaview H.S. |
| 32 | COULSON, Dan (4*) | DODD, Steve (28) | C | Unley Royals | 1947/48 | Blackwood |
| 32 | MARTIN, N (34) | HAYDEN, Phil (4*) | B | Coromandel Ramblers | 1967/68 | Hawthorndene Oval |
| 32 | SIMPSON, Brian (97*) | CRAIG, Peter (8) | A | South Road | 1971/72 | Coromandel Valley P.S. |
| 32 | GALLASCH, Graham (27) | CRAIG, Peter (17*) | A | Hectorville | 1977/78 | Daly Oval |
| 32 | SAKTHIVEL, Sundernathan (7*) | BIRD, Thomas (23) | C | Glenelg ANA II | 2008/09 | Will. Light. Sch. |
| 32 | LOURENS, Josh (79) | HARRIS, Nicholas (0*) | D | North Haven III | 2023/24 | Largs North, South |
| 32 | TAYLOR, Dean (38) | TURNER, Jace (1*) | B | Coromandel Ramblers II | 2023/24 | Hawthorndene Oval |
| 32* | HOPKINS, Bob (18*) | HAYDEN, Phil (14*) | B | St Marks | 1969/70 | Denham Reserve |
| 31 | ASHBY, Keith (21*) | MAGAREY, David (Snr) (12) | B | Malvern Star | 1952/53 | Hewett Oval |
| 31 | MAGAREY, Andrew (45) | SCHMIDT, Ron (9*) | A | South Road | 1967/68 | Hewett Oval |
| 31 | PARKER, John (44) | HAMS, Gary (3*) | E | Eastwood II | 1982/83 | Hawthorndene P.S. |
| 31 | GRIFFIN, Peter (9*) | RATHJEN, John (18) | C | Modbury Heights | 1991/92 | Heights School, Rugby Oval |
| 31 | CRAIG, Peter (25) | KOIRALA, Jai (9*) | E | Westminster OS IV | 2002/03 | Manson Oval |
| 31 | HILLIER, Will (24) | HOSKING, Daniel (11*) | B | North Haven II | 2011/12 | Hewett Oval |
| 31 | NORMAN, Chris (23) | HOSKING, Daniel (13*) | B | ICC Sharks III | 2011/12 | Wirreanda H.S. |
| 31* | WANNAN, Grant (31*) | CARPENTER, Graham (14*) | B | Kenilworth II | 1998/99 | Kenilworth Oval |
| 30 | HEWETT, Jim (20*) | MAGAREY, David (Snr) (11) | C | Kenilworth IV | 1969/70 | South parklands |
| 30 | HOPKINS, Bob (26) | ANDERSON, John (5*) | A | Keswick | 1983/84 | Glengowrie H.S. |
| 30 | WEYGOOD, Ben (85*) | ZACPAL, Peter (10) | C | Keswick III | 1995/96 | Hewett Oval |
| 30 | NORMAN, Stuart (13) | HOSKING, Daniel (6*) | D | ICC Sharks IV | 2004/05 | Wirreanda H.S. |
| 30 | HOSKING, Daniel (8*) | NORMAN, Chris (20) | B | Southern | 2010/11 | Hewett Oval |
| 30 | TAYLOR, Michael (31) | CHAMPION, David (4*) | B | Morphettville Park | 2022/23 | Hewett Oval |
| 30* | HUNTER, Richard (54*) | BRIMBLE, Lee (12*) | B | State Bank | 1984/85 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 30* | GALLASCH, Graham (59*) | HUNTER, Richard (13*) | A | Keswick | 1994/95 | Salesian College Oval |
| 30* | ZACPAL, Peter (13*) | HILLIER, Will (24*) | C | St George | 2007/08 | Hewett Oval |
| 29 | NOBLE, Trevor (14*) | CRAIG, Peter (15) | A | South Road | 1977/78 | Edwardstown Oval |
| 29 | TATTERSAL, Ian (10) | ZACPAL, Peter (12*) | B | Plympton Footballers II | 1989/90 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 29 | HUNTER, Richard (14*) | MAURICI, Lou (14) | A | Plympton Footballers | 1994/95 | Plympton Oval |
| 29 | MORRIS, Adam (49*) | WANNAN, Grant (2) | C | Glenelg ANA II | 2012/13 | Will. Light. Sch. |
| 29* | PUMPHREY, Mitchell (7*) | LAURIE, Mitchell (16*) | C | Grand Masters | 2022/23 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 28 | WINN, Bob (21) | HAYDEN, Phil (4*) | D | Wallis Refrigeration | 1949/50 | Blackwood |
| 28 | BARTLETT, Oliver (32*) | HALSTEAD, Bill (8) | B | Goodwood BaseBall | 1950/51 | Hewett Oval |
| 28 | STUTCHBURY, Mike (44) | MABLESON, Roger (5*) | A | St Marks | 1975/76 | Denham Reserve |
| 28 | HELBIG, Michael (35) | SULLIVAN, Sean (5*) | A | Westminster OS | 1987/88 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 28 | JOHNSON, Ted (117*) | KORENDYK, Steve (8) | D | North Haven IV | 1987/88 | Peter Cousins Memorial Oval |
| 28 | SARD, Aaron (38*) | MALIN, Ryan (7) | D | Plympton Footballers V | 1988/89 | Hewett Oval |
| 28 | WOOD, Leith (24*) | WAINWRIGHT, Todd (6) | B | Norwood Union | 1993/94 | Brookway Park Oval |
| 28 | WANNAN, Grant (15*) | ZACPAL, Peter (13) | C | Westminster OS | 1996/97 | Westmin. Sch. |
| 28 | ZACPAL, Peter (29) | ZACPAL, Simon (4*) | C | Adelaide Cavaliers | 2000/01 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 28 | FITZGERALD, Anthony (6*) | SCHEMBRI, Shane (20) | D | ICC Sharks IV | 2006/07 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 28* | MAGAREY, Roger (Snr) (32*) | DAYMAN, Ivan (13*) | B | Commonwealth Bank | 1948/49 | Hewett Oval |
| 27 | TANNEBRING, Reg (62) | HILLIER, Mark (1*) | B | Kenilworth II | 1971/72 | Coromandel Valley P.S. |
| 27 | STUTCHBURY, Mike (15) | HILLIER, Mark (12*) | B | Mitchell Park II | 1971/72 | Hewett Oval |
| 27 | DENNISON, Brian (52) | GEBERT, Wayne (6*) | A | St Marks | 1993/94 | Denham Reserve |
| 27* | MAGAREY, Andrew (59*) | CARPENTER, Graham (7*) | B | Mitchell Park II | 1997/98 | Mitchell Park Rec. Res. |
| 27* | CHAMPION, Paul (27*) | MITCHELL, Nathan (13*) | C | Bank SA II | 1997/98 | Adelaide Lutheran F.C. |
| 26 | MAGAREY, Alec (54*) | BARTLETT, Oliver (11) | B | Adult Deaf | 1945/46 | South P'lands, Sth Tce |
| 26 | HALSTEAD, Bill (23) | MAGAREY, David (Snr) (10*) | B | Savings Bank | 1954/55 | Walkerville Oval |
| 26 | LEEDHAM, Barry (12*) | NOSWORTHY, Ted (6) | A | Grange | 1963/64 | Hewett Oval |
| 26 | COGDELL, Ian (10) | TANNEBRING, Reg (11*) | A | Plympton Footballers | 1968/69 | Hewett Oval |
| 26 | HELBIG, Greg (9) | HALSTEAD, John (17*) | B | South Road II | 1979/80 | Edwardstown Oval |
| 26 | ALDERSON, Andrew (55) | MARSHALL, Ken (8*) | C | Kenilworth II | 1995/96 | Kenilworth Oval |
| 26 | MATTHEWS, Mike (14) | CHAMPION, Paul (2*) | A | Morphettville Park | 2000/01 | Denham Reserve |
| 26 | ROXBY, Nathan (18*) | CARPENTER, Graham (8) | B | South Park | 2000/01 | Adelaide Lutheran F.C. |
| 26 | JORGENSEN, Brett (26*) | NORMAN, Chris (4) | A | Cove | 2011/12 | Cove F.C. |
| 26 | CHEEK, Max (37) | NORMAN, Chris (5*) | A | Belair | 2012/13 | Hewett Oval |
| 26 | SPRING, Milan (13*) | MACLEAN, Maksim (12) | E | Kenilworth III | 2020/21 | Hawthorndene P.S. |
| 26* | WILKINS, Greg (24*) | HARRIS, Andrew (11*) | D | Plympton Footballers VI | 1996/97 | Hewett Oval |
| 26* | MAGAREY, David (23*) | WANNAN, Grant (8*) | A | Glenelg ANA | 2001/02 | Will. Light. Sch. |
| 25 | STUART, Dick (8*) | DODD, Steve (21) | D | Richmond Park II | 1948/49 | Blackwood |
| 25 | PEDDY, Ross (15) | HALSTEAD, Bill (8*) | B | Newton McLaren | 1955/56 | South P'lands, Sth Tce |
| 25 | HUNTER, Gus (22*) | HAYDEN, John (14) | A | Blackwood R.S.L | 1961/62 | Hawthorndene Oval |
| 25 | POTTER, Tim (36) | MCFARLANE, David (7*) | C | Plympton Footballers III | 1973/74 | Blackwood H.S. |
| 25 | VENNING, Damien (46) | POLKINGHORNE, Chris (18*) | D | North Haven III | 1986/87 | South Parklands |
| 25 | RATHJEN, Peter (24*) | KAETHNER, Tim (6) | B | Glenelg ANA II | 1998/99 | Plympton H.S. |
| 25 | NORMAN, Stuart (4) | ZACPAL, Peter (17*) | D | ICC Sharks IV | 2005/06 | Wirreanda H.S. |
| 25 | BEVERLEY, John (32) | BRUCE, Gareth (5*) | A | Plympton Footballers | 2005/06 | Hewett Oval |
| 25* | HARVEY, Andrew (16*) | PEACOCK, Sam (14*) | C | Plympton Footballers III | 1993/94 | Hewett Oval |
| 25* | CLARKE, Ben (32*) | LLOYD, Rowan (6*) | C | Camden Beach | 2001/02 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 24 | MAGAREY, David (Snr) (10) | PENNO, John (9*) | B | Unley Oval | 1945/46 | Hewett Oval |
| 24 | BROWN, L (24) | MOWATT, Geoff (0*) | A | Shell | 1965/66 | South P'lands, Sth Tce |
| 24 | HUNTER, Gus (30) | KAHL, Jeff (9*) | C | Karana | 1981/82 | Findon P.S. |
| 24 | LANE, David (31*) | LITTLEFIELD, Jason (8) | B | Mitchell Park III | 1987/88 | Mitchell Park H.S |
| 24 | HAMLYN, Chris (18*) | SARD, Jeff / Geoff (12) | D | North Haven III | 1988/89 | Peter Cousins Memorial Oval |
| 24 | NEEDHAM, Patrick (26*) | LANE, David (13) | B | South Road | 2005/06 | Hewett Oval |
| 24 | FITZGERALD, Anthony (34*) | KERNICH, Ben (5) | D | Woodcroft | 2007/08 | Woodcroft P.S. |
| 24 | MAGAREY, David (82*) | HODGKINSON, Kyle (5) | B | ICC Sharks III | 2011/12 | Hewett Oval |
| 24 | JORGENSEN, Brett (7*) | MUGGRIDGE, Anthony (20) | A | Morphettville Park | 2011/12 | Denham Reserve |
| 24 | BROWN, Andrew (30*) | MITTIGA, Jack (8) | A | Warradale | 2018/19 | Hewett Oval |
| 24 | BRUCE, Gareth (32) | WALTON, Jack (4*) | A | ICC Sharks | 2021/22 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 24 | VAN DEN BOS, Cameron (20) | MACLEAN, Maksim (0*) | A | ICC Sharks | 2022/23 | Hewett Oval |
| 24* | HOSKING, Daniel (17*) | NORMAN, Chris (14*) | B | Coromandel Ramblers II | 2010/11 | Hawthorndene Oval |
| 23 | SLEE, Arthur (27*) | MAGAREY, David (Snr) (5) | B | South Road III | 1956/57 | Forbes P.S. |
| 23 | HAYDEN, Phil (37*) | GAMBLE, Graham (6) | B | Newton McLaren | 1963/64 | Hewett Oval |
| 23 | WICKS, Richard (21*) | JOHNSTON, Mark (11) | D | Hectorville III | 1982/83 | Hewett Oval |
| 23 | LEEDHAM, Barry (41*) | WANNAN, Grant (5) | C | State Bank II | 1987/88 | Cnr Peacock Rd, Greenhill Rd … |
| 23 | CARPENTER, Bruce (68*) | ATTIWILL, Scott (8) | C | Mitchell Park IV | 1989/90 | Hewett Oval |
| 23 | EGLINTON, Mark (19) | MCCORMICK, Jeremy (13*) | A | Western Youth Centre | 2000/01 | Hewett Oval |
| 23 | BRUCE, Gareth (15*) | MAGAREY, David (11) | A | Morphettville Park | 2004/05 | Denham Reserve |
| 23 | BRUCE, Gareth (16) | KOIRALA, Jai (7*) | A | ICC Sharks | 2005/06 | Hewett Oval |
| 23 | ZACPAL, Peter (23) | RAJAN, Tarun (5*) | C | Sheidow Park III | 2007/08 | Sheidow Park P.S. |
| 23 | LAY, Chris (15*) | HODGKINSON, Kyle (7) | A | Westminster OS | 2008/09 | Westmin. Sch. |
| 23 | DRAPER, Daniel (5*) | SCOTT, Ben (17) | A | Sheidow Park | 2014/15 | Capella Rd. Res. |
| 23 | VAN DEN BOS, Cameron (23*) | PATTISON, Lachlan (0) | A | Sheidow Park | 2020/21 | Hewett Oval |
| 23* | BAYLY, Mark (38*) | RATHJEN, John (10*) | D | Coromandel Ramblers IV | 1990/91 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 23* | ALDERSON, Andrew (34*) | MAGAREY, David (9*) | A | Panorama | 1999/00 | Hewett Oval |
| 22 | WATCHMAN, Harold (29*) | WILSON, J (10) | A | St Marks | 1947/48 | Hewett Oval |
| 22 | ASHBY, Keith (128*) | MAGAREY, David (Snr) (5) | B | Malvern Star | 1951/52 | Hewett Oval |
| 22 | SCOTT, Bill (14*) | STOWARD, Des (7) | A | Kenilworth | 1952/53 | Hewett Oval |
| 22 | MACKERETH, Don (20*) | STUART, Dick (13) | A | Grange | 1953/54 | Hewett Oval |
| 22 | BARTLETT, Oliver (17) | MAGAREY, David (Snr) (7*) | B | Sturt II | 1954/55 | Marion Oval |
| 22 | NOSWORTHY, Ted (33) | SPRING, Mike (5*) | A | Kenilworth | 1964/65 | Hewett Oval |
| 22 | TANNEBRING, Reg (18*) | DONOVAN, J (12) | B | Belair | 1966/67 | Hewett Oval |
| 22 | PARKER, Jeff (16) | WANNAN, Grant (4*) | C | Norwood Union II | 1984/85 | Adelaide University |
| 22 | MABLESON, Roger (20) | CRAIG, Peter (9*) | A | Hectorville | 1985/86 | Daly Oval |
| 22 | HAYDEN, Mark (67) | GOOCH, Mark (8*) | A | Warradale | 1990/91 | Plympton Football Grd |
| 22 | GARTH, Chris (7*) | ZACPAL, Simon (12) | D | St George III | 2000/01 | Parklands, Park 21 |
| 22 | LANGMAID, Andrew (101*) | WANNAN, Grant (4) | A | Keswick | 2000/01 | Adelaide H.S. |
| 22 | MCCAULEY, Jarrod (9) | ZACPAL, Peter (9*) | C | North Haven II | 2002/03 | Largs North, South |
| 22 | MAGAREY, Michael (13*) | CRAIG, Peter (12) | D | Sheidow Park IV | 2003/04 | Sheidow Park P.S. |
| 22 | NEEDHAM, Patrick (44*) | OAKEY, Rahsaan (8) | B | Coromandel Ramblers II | 2005/06 | Hewett Oval |
| 22 | CHEEK, Sam (42*) | CARMAN, Liam (3) | A | Plympton Footballers | 2008/09 | Plympton Oval |
| 22 | ZADOW, Joseph (61) | NORMAN, Chris (6*) | B | Woodcroft | 2015/16 | Hewett Oval |
| 22 | VAN DEN BOS, Cameron (17*) | MACLEAN, Maksim (3) | A | Sheidow Park | 2022/23 | Sheidow Park P.S. |
| 22* | GRIFFIN, Peter (11*) | THOMAS, Ian (9*) | D | Norwood Union III | 1986/87 | Hewett Oval |
| 22* | ZACPAL, Simon (32*) | GARTH, Chris (1*) | C | Panorama II | 2001/02 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 22* | VANDELEUR, Harrison (21*) | HARRIS, Nicholas (1*) | E | Western Youth Centre III | 2022/23 | Cowandilla P.S |
| 21 | BARTLETT, Oliver (12) | FOSTER, Harold (12*) | B | Goodwood BaseBall | 1949/50 | Hewett Oval |
| 21 | ALLEY, Alf (38*) | HALSTEAD, Bill (16) | B | Kenilworth II | 1954/55 | Hewett Oval |
| 21 | HAYDEN, John (12) | HAYDEN, John (12) | A | Fulham | 1956/57 | Hewett Oval |
| 21 | HEWETT, Russell (26*) | VALENTINE, Geoff (6) | A | Fulham | 1965/66 | Hewett Oval |
| 21 | HEWETT, Mike (31) | WAUCHOPE, Steve (15*) | B | Kenilworth II | 1969/70 | Kenilworth Oval |
| 21 | WORTHINGTON, Alan (10) | HALSTEAD, John (14*) | C | St Marks II | 1971/72 | Denham Reserve |
| 21 | AUBURY, Mel (9*) | HELBIG, Greg (8) | D | M.P.S.M. IV | 1977/78 | Blackwood H.S. |
| 21 | HUNTER, Richard (38*) | ANDERSON, John (1) | A | Mitchell Park | 1986/87 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 21 | BAUM, Sam (18) | MALIN, Ryan (5*) | B | Sheidow Park | 1990/91 | Hewett Oval |
| 21 | RATHJEN, John (16) | GRIFFIN, Peter (5*) | C | ANZ III | 1991/92 | South Parklands |
| 21 | COULTER, Darren (38*) | WANNAN, Grant (4) | A | ICC Sharks | 2002/03 | Wirreanda H.S. |
| 21 | HODGKINSON, Mitchell (10) | HARRISON, Ashley (11*) | B | Plympton Footballers II | 2005/06 | Plympton Oval |
| 21 | KOIRALA, Jai (118) | NORMAN, Chris (3*) | A | North Haven | 2009/10 | North Haven F.C. |
| 21 | JONES, Jesse (16*) | KEARSLEY, Greg (13) | D | South Park | 2009/10 | Kenilworth Oval |
| 21 | APTHOMAS, Daniel (13*) | MUGGRIDGE, Anthony (8) | A | Western Youth Centre | 2011/12 | Western Youth Centre |
| 21 | HAND, Nathan (18) | MCMANUS, Josh (10*) | B | Happy Valley | 2021/22 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 21 | HAWKINS, Ben (41*) | MCMANUS, Josh (1) | B | Sheidow Park | 2021/22 | Sheidow Park P.S. |
| 21* | MADDERN, Bert (17*) | BAILLIE, Ivan (14*) | B | Eastwood | 1949/50 | Hewett Oval |
| 21* | TAYLOR, Michael (15*) | EAMES, Jack (10*) | B | Coromandel Ramblers II | 2022/23 | Hewett Oval |
| 20 | HAYDEN, John (15) | MCGOUGH, Jack (9*) | D | Kenilworth II | 1949/50 | Blackwood |
| 20 | EVANS, Dave (22*) | HALSTEAD, Bill (9) | B | Belair | 1952/53 | Belair National Park |
| 20 | SLEE, Arthur (14) | SLEE, Bruce (2*) | B | Harris Scarfe | 1960/61 | South P'lands, Sth Tce |
| 20 | JENNER, Eric (62) | MAGAREY, David (Snr) (6*) | C | Salesian O.B.A. | 1966/67 | Blackwood H.S. |
| 20 | THOMPSON, P (28*) | MAGAREY, John (0) | C | Mitchell Park III | 1969/70 | Blackwood H.S. |
| 20 | HAYDEN, Phil (16*) | STUTCHBURY, Mike (4) | B | Mitchell Park II | 1971/72 | Hewett Oval |
| 20 | MAGAREY, Rob (6*) | HUNTER, Gus (18) | A | St Marks | 1972/73 | Morphettville Park P.S. |
| 20 | DUNN, Ken (36) | MARSLAND, Glenn (10*) | B | South Road II | 1973/74 | Edwardstown Oval |
| 20 | CRAIG, Peter (22) | MABLESON, Roger (0*) | A | Plympton Footballers | 1975/76 | Plympton Oval |
| 20 | CRAIG, Peter (7) | ANDERSON, John (15*) | A | South Road | 1983/84 | Edwardstown Oval |
| 20 | JEANS, Steven (33*) | SELLICK, Rohan (4) | D | Glenelg Lacrosse II | 1983/84 | Henley Beach H.S |
| 20 | JONES, Mark (75) | MARSHALL, Ken (0*) | C | Saints | 1990/91 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 20 | LANE, David (39) | HAGLEY, Tom (7*) | A | Keswick | 1992/93 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 20 | HELBIG, Michael (24) | RATHJEN, Peter (2*) | A | Warradale | 1992/93 | Plympton H.S. |
| 20 | MANGIN, Brodie (17) | ROXBY, Nathan (3*) | A | Glenelg ANA | 2002/03 | Hewett Oval |
| 20 | CARMAN, Liam (17*) | MUGGRIDGE, Anthony (9) | E | ICC Sharks V | 2005/06 | Manson Oval |
| 20 | LAY, Chris (31) | NORMAN, Chris (4*) | A | Sheidow Park | 2008/09 | Capella Rd. Res. |
| 20 | WRIGHT, Chris (99) | HOSKING, Daniel (4*) | B | ICC Sharks III | 2009/10 | Wirreanda H.S. |
| 20 | FRENCH, Patrick (6*) | FUNNELL, Haydn (11) | C | Mitchell Park | 2013/14 | Blackwood Hill Oval |
| 20* | HEWETT, Bob (28*) | NOSWORTHY, Ted (5*) | A | Taxation | 1956/57 | St. Peters ground |
| 20* | BUET, Andrew (23*) | ZACPAL, Peter (2*) | D | Southern Warriors II | 2022/23 | Marion P.S. |